Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 and 18 discussion

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Hina

This is a review and discussion of the live action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon series Acts 17, Minako Transforms in Front of Rei’s Eyes, and 18, At Last, All 5 Sailor Guardians Are Together. These episodes aired on Japanese television January 31st and February 7th 2004. They focus on the appearance of Mamoru’s girlfriend Hina and the shipping of Sailor Mars and Sailor Venus.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Mamoru checks out Usagi while Hina is jealous Distracted Boyfriend or Man Looking at Other Woman meme

Act 17 starts off where Act 16 ended with Usagi running into Mamoru and Hina. They do this awkward thing where they reshoot the events of the last episode which sort of already happened, having Mamoru react to seeing Usagi with Hina on his arm. I can’t help but notice how similar the scene of Mamoru looking at Usagi while Hina looks at him is to the recent meme of the “Distracted Boyfriend” or “Man Looking at Other Woman” which I’ve posted about a number of times. I’ve included both for reference. Hina asks if that girl is there to see him and Mamoru, being totally awkward and ignorant, assumes she is not because she didn’t speak up. He really should know better! The source of the conflict here is not Hina but Mamoru! Hina is portrayed by actress Moeco Matsushita who we’ll be seeing for a number of additional episodes.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Minako faints

Meanwhile Minako continues to be on the run! We see that she’s hiding out in a hotel with a painting of a greek temple on the wall. Is she in Greece, like she did in the Sailor V manga? Almost certainly not as she quickly ends up hiding out in a Church in Tokyo and then back at the hotel, so it’s likely a local one. We see Minako faint, which is the first tangible indication of her mysterious illness which will be a plot point for most of the rest of the series. The specifics of this illness are never explicitly described but for the purposes of the show it’s some sort of supposedly terminal illness which she is suffering. In the interest of those who may not have seen the entire series I won’t get into more specifics until they play out.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Usagi chose the right yarn

At school Usagi’s home ec teacher, or whatever we call that kind of class in Japan, is giving the students a project to make a scarf and give it to someone special such as, and she actually suggests this, a boyfriend! This seems like a large amount of pressure to put on a bunch of young teenage girls but whatever I’m no educator! Usagi is clearly torn as she wants to make the scarf for Mamoru but that would be mildly inappropriate given he apparently has a girlfriend and so she instead decides to make the scarf for Tuxedo Mask because that’s a totally different person. She picks out the perfect yarn to match Tuxedo Mask, which is white, and proceeds to neglect her knitting as she drowns her sorrows in some very intense karaoke of, naturally, “C’est la vie”.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Hina is actually really nice

While the scarf is only partially complete Usagi literally runs into Mamoru and Hina. Hina’s reaction? She’s apologetic and deeply concerned that Usagi may have ruined her scarf which is clearly intended for a special person who she doesn’t realize is actually her boyfriend. A lesser show would have made Hina evil so that Usagi would be justified in trying to steal her boyfriend. This isn’t a lesser show! It’s Sailor Moon! By making Hina a kind and caring person it just complicates and puts a more realistic spin on this drama. Most love triangles don’t involve a “good guy” and “bad guy” pining after the same person. The real world is more nuanced! Usagi is devastated by this finally empathizing with Hina and realizing what a nice person she is.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei's mother Risa Hino's grave

It is the anniversary of Rei’s mother’s death, meaning that she died around January 31st. Her tomb stone notes that her name is Risa Hino and that she lived from 1963 to 1995. This puts her at about 32 years old when she died. Rei is about 14 at the beginning of the series, in 2003, so she would be about 6 when her mother died. This seems to roughly fit with the age of the various versions of young Rei we see in flashbacks when her mother dies. Rei would have been born when her mother was around 26 which also seems like a pretty reasonable age to have a child. No inconsistencies here from the prop department! Risa Hino is buried, or at least has a grave marker dedicated to her, at a Christian church in Tokyo. This seems a bit odd to me as I learned from a fantastic book, Warriors of Legend: Reflections of Japan in Sailor Moon, that only foreigners are usually buried in Japan as laws require Japanese born citizens to be cremated. Rei appears to be fully Japanese and Risa is a common Japanese given name not often found in other cultures. Still this church has an English speaking white priest who has an accent when speaking Japanese and occasionally says things in English. While speaking to the priest we learn that Rei hates her father for working while her mother was dying.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei prays to her mother at St. Juban Church

Speaking of this church, it’s clearly not a real church! Well not all of it. The various signs refer to it as “St. Juban Church”. How to break this down… a Saint is a person, generally a human, who is determined by in this case the Catholic church to be holy and given the title of Saint. Juban is a place, not a person. It is a reference to Azabu-Juban (or Juuban). It is a neighbourhood in the Azabu district in Tokyo. One might wonder if Juban is named after a person who might be the Saint this church is referencing? Not really possible. Juuban means “10th” or “Number 10″ so it’s like saying the 10th neighbourhood in Azabu which means it isn’t named after a person. St. Juban is not only not an actual Saint but the concept of such a Saint doesn’t make much sense.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Sailor Mars and Sailor Venus in the St. Juban Church gymnasium

Further a lot of the shots of this church are clearly just taking place in a gymnasium which looks like a school gymnasium. It actually looks very similar to the gym that Minako plays volleyball in Sailor Moon S episode 100, I Want to Quit Being a Sailor Guardian: Minako’s Dilemma. I know there is a school gym later in the series but I don’t recall if it’s the same set. Do some churches include school type gymnasiums? This seems plausible but I’m not expert in the Japanese Christian Church scene. The area, which has a podium and projected cross on the stage, clearly has basketball nets visible as well as lines on the ground for various sports. My primary school and many others I’ve visited had this sort of gym/stage set up so that large gatherings such as graduations or school plays could be held in the gymnasium rather than requiring the school to have a large and expensive auditorium. Another variant on this type of amalgam is the cafetorium, which is a mix of a cafeteria and auditorium. While a lot of the action in Act 17 takes place in the gym there are also other parts to this church including a proper chapel. While these could all be part of a real church in Tokyo, which I couldn’t find any specific information on, it may also be the case that these are just a number of locations used for these episodes that were dressed up with a few prop crosses and Christian decorations to make them seem like part of a single church. Alternatively the gymnasium may have been part of a school affiliated with the church. As a child I attended cubs at a Christian school which was next door to an affiliated church which I also attended at Christmas time. The school and church shared and name and both had crosses and Christian imagery displayed throughout. That school’s gym also had a stage in it!

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Minako recognizes Sailor Mars

This church is the stage of major Minako/Rei shipping! This is a prominent friendship and somewhat complex relationship of the series and this is just the beginning. Minako nearly immediately notices that Rei is Sailor Mars, because she’s good at that, but Rei can’t do the same. Instead she seems to notice something but it’s actually that Minako is well known pop idol Minako Aino, something that almost any other girl her age would have noticed. This reminds me a bit of Usagi who fails to recognize who Seiya of the Three Lights is despite the fact that he’s a big star. Minako was at the Church praying which may insinuate that she is Christian in this continuity. Though Rei is visiting her mother it’s not clear how much she may be an observing Christian. She attends a Catholic girls school in the manga and anime despite being a Shinto priest. She may simply be visiting her mother’s grave though she is kneeling and praying in a Christian fashion. I wonder if either Minako or Rei feel that their own godlike powers are at odds with their various religious beliefs. My understanding of religious beliefs in Japan is that many people will simultaneously observe certain practices of conflicting religions without any real concern. There is a lost sick dog which shows up at the Church and Minako and Rei seem to think it’s their responsibility to care for him which is the excuse for them to remain around and interacting with each other for a couple of episodes.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Dancers make Sailor Venus blonde

After the monster attack Rei immediately transforms but Minako hesitates, unwilling to give up her secret identity. Finally she does and we are exposed to the most ridiculous of transformation sequences to date! The best part is when these gymnastic dancers frolic through her hair to make it blonde! I guess in the continuity of the show this is their actual hair and not awful wigs! During the fight Sailor Venus is injured by an exploding sword and Sailor Mars stops to help her, still under the impression that she is Princess Serenity. Sailor Venus chastises her for this and so we are introduced to the Venus/Mars conflict which just make this ship that much better!

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Sailor Venus and Sailor Mars face off

Act 18 again starts where we left off, with Sailor Mars and Venus fighting! Sailor Mars doubles down saying she wouldn’t have had to stick around if Venus had been better in battle! Venus insists that she doesn’t want to be protected by the rest of the Sailor Guardians. How odd! She’s the Princess, isn’t she??? Later in the episode she clarifies to Sailor Mars that she should never leave Sailor Moon’s side and that this is an order from the Princess! What a curious order from someone who we should suspect is the one that should be protected!

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Rei is jealous of Minako's poster

The Rei/Minako feud continues in the form of taking care of the dog! Rei shows up with a big bag of cheap dog food so moneybags Minako goes out and buys premium healthy canned dog foot! All well and good but he’ll get sick if he’s not used to eating wet food. Rei refers to the dog as Taro and Minako refers to him as Riki. In order to help find Taro/Riki’s owner the two make signs. So they make a little flyer with a photo of the dog on the computer and make some photocopies because it’s 2004 and such a thing is easily done? We did see Minako use Photoshop Elements not long ago! Well no. Each of them hand paints a lost dog sign complete with a painting of the dog! Rei puts up her small but fairly elaborate sign and Minako, who should be working on her new album, hangs a much larger sign! Humourous if not completely ridiculous! This of course is a proxy fight taking the place of their actual argument which is rooted in misunderstanding. We can note here that Luna seems to share knowledge of Sailor Venus’s identity as she is there at the poster feuding and speaks to Minako. When speaking to Artemis Minako seems to regret what she said to Rei but the next time she sees her she spews out the exact same arguments! Why don’t these two just get along?

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Usagi images placing a scarf on Mamoru

Meanwhile Usagi’s scarf isn’t going well. Her teacher calls her out and says it’s more like a handkerchief. Hilarious! She’s already given two handkerchiefs to Tuxedo Mask/Mamoru. Why not a third to go with his collection that he has going on his nightstand? While confiding in Makoto and Ami she reveals what we’d all figured out. She wasn’t really thinking of Tuxedo Mask when she was making this thing. She was thinking of Mamoru. Well okay she was actually thinking of Tuxedo Mask anyway but she didn’t actually know that. In her mind they are still separate entities.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Makoto empathizes

Makoto’s reactions to Usagi’s unfolding emotions are impressive. Just seeing the look in her face shows so much. She’s really feeling Usagi’s pain and, knowing what we do about her recent unrequited love, I like to think this also played into the way she acts and feels here. Ami similarly feels pain for Usagi but she doesn’t have the emotional baggage to really feel it like Makoto does.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Motoki and Makoto on a pseudo date

Makoto has some advice for Usagi! Don’t give up even if he has a girlfriend! She might not stick around! This reminds me of episode 30 of the original Sailor Moon anime, Total Chaos: the Messy Love Rectangle, in which Usagi and Makoto find out that Motoki has a girlfriend and Makoto is unphased! Of course in this continuity Motoki is quite single, so Makoto arranges a meeting with him to grill him about Mamoru’s girlfriend. Have I mentioned I’m shipping these two? This isn’t the first hint at a relationship between these two we’ll see and there’s more to come! Motoki is disappointed that Makoto wasn’t interested in a date with him, but Makoto gives him some turtle food and all is well. Motoki confirms that Mamoru indeed has a girlfriend and that her name is Hina. He says that Usagi should give up on Mamoru since he and Hina are in love. That’s great Motoki! Where was this wisdom when Naru asked him for Mamoru’s contact information so that she could set Usagi and him up? I guess Motoki just isn’t that great with women.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Young Hina and Mamoru

Now that we know a bit about Hina, we get a bit of backstory. Hina and Mamoru have known each other since they were children when Mamoru said that one day he’d marry Hina! I used to say stuff like this to girls when I was like 5 years old as well but I never married any of them! If you liked it, Mamoru, then you should have put a ring on it. With all the jewellery theft he does in his night life he had ample opportunity to make it official! Right so we see young versions of Hina and Mamoru in this one scene and as luck would have it the Church that Hina wants to get married in is none other than St. Juban Church, home of the holiest church gym in all of Tokyo! In this case they are in a legit church, where the priest turns out to be the monster who actually was a separate entity in episode 17 but whatever. The monster probably possessed the priest. Everyone is knocked unconscious except for Mamoru and Hina who escape to the church gymnasium and pass out!

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - The Sailor Guardians with Sailor Venus in the middle Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - The Sailor Team with Sailor Moon in the middle

Everyone is called to the church gym and for the first time in the series all five of the Sailor Guardians are together! There’s a cool series of shots that takes place here showing all of the Guardians in order with Sailor Venus, the Princess, in the middle. Seen from a different angle however we see the Sailor Guardians with Sailor Moon in the middle. The camera lingers on this shot for a moment. What could this mean??? If you haven’t figured it out you probably aren’t paying attention and aren’t familiar with any other continuity! This is the part in the series where the online arguments between the Sailor Venus is the Princess and Sailor Moon is the Princess camps became really heated. I recall someone at the Genvid forums pointing out this fact and it seemed like a slam dunk to me. There’s even a basketball net in the background! Dunks for Jesus!

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Mamoru and Hina holding hands

The monster is dispatched and afterwards the gang find Mamoru and Hina unconscious, holding each other’s hands. Sailor Moon mentions that love is always a good thing, and so she’s accepted Hina’s feelings but also accepted how she feels about Mamoru. Amazing. How many people would look at such a situation with such optimism? Once again we see that the strength of Usagi’s heart, rather than that of Sailor Moon and her Crystal, are what really make her the exceptional hero that she is! Sailor Moon quickly heals the two which makes me wonder… could she heal someone’s terminal illness with that thing? She is seen regularly healing people who have had their energy drained by the Dark Kingdom but could she heal cancer or pneumonia with that thing too? Seems relevant since …

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Minako only has 6 months

Back at the hotel room Minako is chatting with Artemis. He suggests that she may be pushing away the other girls in order to spare their feelings. She mentions that she only has 6 months left. Six months until what exactly?

Feel free to leave a comment with your own thoughts on these two episodes. If you’re looking to watch along with the series you can get English subtitled fan subbed versions from sites such as Miss Dream, TV-Nihon and Sea of Serenity. Fans looking to stream the show can do so from Dramanice and Kiss Asian.

Keep reading for more screenshots from these episodes.

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Usagi eats away her emotions

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Usagi is unenthusiastic about knitting

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei hates her father

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Minako prays at St. Juban Church

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei and Minako care for a stray

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei doesn't recognize Sailor V

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei recognizes Minako Aino

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Usagi distracts herself with karaoke

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei smilesLive Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei smiles

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei/Minako shipping

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Mamoru surprised to see Usagi

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Hina

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Usagi notices that Hina is actually super nice

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Makoto empathizes

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Usagi is sad

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Rei in the Church gymnasium auditorium

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Minako transforms

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Sailor Venus transforms

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Dancers make Sailor Venus's bow

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Sailor Venus

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Sailor Venus

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Sailor Venus

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Sailor Venus

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 - Artemis preaches

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Usagi contemplates her scarf

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Rei has cheap dog food

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Minako has expensive dog food

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Rei and Minako argue

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Makoto grills Motoki about Mamoru's girlfriend

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Young Hina

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Minako makes an excessively elaborate poster

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Minako makes an excessively elaborate dog poster

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Rei's cheap but still elaborate posters

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Sailor Moon smiles

Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 18 - Usagi knits her scarf with renewed interest

Possibly Related Posts

 


This entry was posted in Uncategorized by Adam. Bookmark the permalink.

12 thoughts on “Live Action Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon Act 17 and 18 discussion

  1. Oh, the Rei/Minako shippers!

    I personally feel like they’re just really good friends who grow to have a deep understanding of each other, and the lives that they, as Sailor Guardians, are living.

  2. I hummed Venus’ henshin music the whole time reading this one.
    duh-dun-dun-dah…dah-dun-dun-dun!

    I can see Minako having some Christian beliefs, but with Rei, maybe her mother had some Christian beliefs that she hung on to and that’s why she was buried here. Or maybe it’s her father who had it done, since I can also imagine it being him who put her into Catholic School.
    I read one time that even though Usagi and Haruka often wear crosses that it’s more for the fashion than religion, same with Usagi’s intense desire to get married in a church.
    I guess we’ll never know for sure and maybe it’s not our business anyway! XD

    Some churches do have gymnasiums, though most of the ones I attended as a child had them as a separate building.

    • That is a very interesting topic!

      My point of view about Usagi’s intense desire to marry in a church is that it has something to see with the strong admiration some Japanese people have for Western culture(s) (Europe, America), even though they don’t know anything of it/them. Of course, this admiration is made of fantasy, it’s a fascination only fed by clichés, because they don’t know the reality of living in the West. A lot of people do have a fascination for other countries/languages/cultures than theirs, an idealized vision that does not correspond to the everyday reality of the real life within the place they admire from afar. In Usagi’s case, she seems to consider that marrying in a church is a very romantic act (and, to be fair, it is true that Christian weddings seem more romantic than the traditional Japanese weddings, which seem rather severe), nothing else: the religious dimension is, in my opinion, absent from Usagi’s and Mamoru’s thoughts. Also, having the couple marry in a church sticks more to the Western Tradition (that is a mix between pagan beliefs, Christian beliefs, and greek and latin classics) that the Moon and the Earth kingdoms seemed to embody, back in the Silver Millenium time.

      As for the crosses worn by both Usagi and Haruka, I’d say that indeed, this is more for the fashion than religion. The latin cross has become a fashion accessory that you can wear to get a “rockish” aura.

      • I don’t know about Haruka though, she doesn’t strike me as being at all the type to sport a religious symbol like that glibly. And she does seem to have a sort of Catholic guilt/Sartrian existentialist thing going.

        • If only Naoko Takeuchi had explored these characters deeper! I’m sure there’s so much interesting we still don’t know.

          I’d love to explore religions in Sailor Moon in a way that is respectful to everyone involved. I know Shinto, Christianity and Buddhism all show up from time to time during the series.

          It’s a hot/touchy topic, but interesting to me.

          • And “Crystal Tokyo” is a fairly obvious pun on the Japanese word for Christianity (“Kirisutokyo”).

            Speaking of background music, does anyone know if Marty Simon wrote any of the score for the DiC OST? “Mercury Computer Scan” and much of the score for the DiC dub of the R season (particularly the “lost” epsodes) sound very like the OST for Lexx.

          • Interesting observation. Can’t say I ever watched enough Lexx to notice. I’m not too sure where you would be able to get such information. Roland Parliament might be the best person to ask as he was the director for those dubbed episodes. I don’t recall anything about the music being mentioned in his book Sailor Moon Reflections though.

          • The DiC credits just credit Don Perry Music, so they’re not very helpful. The DiC OST tracks pretty much seem to fall into three categories–“scary/creepy/sounds basically like the original OST”, “goofy/ragtime/sounds kind of like Seeing Things“, and “airy/mystical/sounds a whole lot like Lexx“.

            Further on religion, one thing I’ve noticed is the R season design of Sailor Moon’s broach–a five point star (Christianity) inset with a star-crescent (Islam), and on the inside, the facets of the Silver Crystal form a six-point star (Judaism).

          • Wow, I never thought that about the brooch, that’s amazing. Not sure if that’s intentional, but you’re right!

  3. I don’t know why the subs refuse to admit that Hina is Mamoru’s fiance. In the scene where Mako-chan is questioning Motoki, he admits that Mamoru is engaged and will be getting married. Many times where the subs say girlfriend it’s actually Fiance (Konyakusha).

Leave a Reply to Williukea Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>